Author Archives: workingvis

Brunel 2.0 Preview

Published by:

We’ve been quiet on this site for a little while; few examples as we’ve been working on new features for our upcoming 2.0 release in August. Here’s the current version of the release notes, showing what new features will be added:

2.0 Release Notes


Brunel is now accessible. By specifying the accessibility flag in BuilderOptions
(also by using -accessibility as n option for the command-line tools), then Brunel generates
SVG with Aria roles and labels so as to allow aria compliant screen readers to read the
content of items. The content is currently in English only. Veuillez nous excuser.

Brunel adds region roles to major areas, such as elements (in a multi-element chart),
charts (in a multi-chart visualization), axes and legends. This should allow the user to use
a compliant navigation system to navigate through the major blocks and arrive at the one you
desire rapidly.

The system has been tested with Apple’s Voice Over technology, but we are actively looking
for feedback on this feature, particularly how we can improve it to make it more useful for
all people, rather than merely compliant.

High-contrast views can be mostly achieved by use of a custom-designed style sheet. This is
not an area we have addressed in this release.



Gridlines have been brought back in Brunel, and additional syntax added for them.
Previously gridlines were generated by default, but were styled to be invisible.
Also, they didn’t work well …

The new way to request gridlines is to use a grid modifier on an axes() command
to request them, for example:

x(summer) y(winter) axes(x:grid, y:grid)
x(summer) y(winter) axes(x:grid:50, y:grid)
x(Summer) y(Population:log) axes(x, y:grid)

Standard CSS styling applies to the grid lines; you can set it in the style sheet you use,
or define it either for both sets of gridlines, or individually:

x(Summer) y(Population) axes(x:grid, y:grid) style('.grid {stroke:green}')
x(Summer) y(Population) axes(x:grid, y:grid) style('.grid{opacity:1}
   .grid.y {stroke-dasharray:5,5} .grid.x {stroke-width:40px; opacity:0.2}')


label-location is now supported on styles for axis title locations, and can be used to place the
axes titles relative to the axis. We have also improved support for large title fonts.
Below is an example of this in operation:

x(Region) y(dem_rep) transpose tooltip(#all)
style('.axis .title { fill:red; label-location:right; font-size:60px }')

Padding and mark sizes

We now support padding in the CSS for text elements associated with axes and legends.
padding, padding-left, padding-right, padding-top and padding-bottom are all supported,
with standard units EXCEPT that we do not support percentage padding.

Here is an example of the use with axes:

bar x(Winter) y(#count) sort(#count) tooltip(#all) bin(Winter)
style('.axis .title {fill:red;label-location:left; padding-left:1in}

We also now use the css size for the tick mark (.tick line) to determmine its size.

The following Brunel is long and ugly, but shows all the styles in action:

x(winter) y(summer) style('.axis.y .tick text{fill:red;padding-right:10px}')
title('Ugly Style test')
style('.axis.x .tick text{fill:blue;font-size:1cm; padding:2mm} .axis .tick line{size:-5mm} ')
style('.axis .title {label-location:left;font-size:20px}')
style('.axis .title {label-location:left;font-size:20px;font-style:italic;padding-left:1in}')
style('.header {fill:red;font-size:40px;padding-bottom:50px;label-location:right}')


Elements that have been selected now have the css class ‘selection’ defined for them.
This allows you to use style definitions for custom display of selected elements, as
in the below:

point x(Longitude) y(Latitude) color(region) size(population:1000%)
style('.selected {opacity:0.5; stroke-opacity:1; stroke-width:2; stroke-dasharray:2 2}
.element {opacity:0.2}') interaction(select:mouseover)

Labels for elements that are selected also have the selected class defined, so you
can modify selected labels’ appearances using styles. In this version, we only
support one position modifier — vertical-align. If this value is set to a pixel value
(such as 20px or -30px) it will move the text the indicated amount AFTER placement

Here is a long sample with a lot of styling going on for text:

data('sample:whiskey.csv') bar x(category) y(#count) transpose
size(#selection:[20%, 80%]) sort(#count:ascending) label(category) axes(y)
style('.label.selected {fill:yellow; text-shadow:0px 0px 4px black; vertical-align:18px; text-transform:uppercase}')
style('label-location:outside-top-right; text-align:end; padding:1px')

Another modification was done to how we hand overlapping data labels; previously they were
removed from the display, but now they are given the class overlap which our default
style sheet hides, but you can modify to treat any way you want. For example:

data('sample:whiskey.csv') point x(Age) y(Price) label(category:5)
style('.overlap {visibility:visible; text-shadow:none; opacity:0.2}')

Axis ranges

The initial range of a numeric field can be set by defining a range for the x or y
command, much like a transform. Examples are:

point x(Longitude:[-100, -80]) y(Latitude:[35, 45])


We have added a new feature to allow an element to define a guide. This is described more fully in
the complete documentation, but here is an example showing its use:

x(winter) y(summer) + guide(y:40+x, y:70, y:'70+10*sin(x)')
style('.guide1{stroke:red} .guide3 {stroke-dasharray:none}')


A new animate command has been added that provides an interactive control to animate a visualization over
the values of a continuous field. As part of this, labels on continuous filters have improved (particularly for date fields).

The interaction(select) command and also the new callback event command interaction(call:func)
can now take an event name parameter snap that allows interactivity to be fired when the
mouse is near a data item on screen

interaction(call:func) has been added; the ability to call bak to a javascript function to handle
events in special ways. A new page in the documentation describes the API.

interaction(panzoom) can now take options x, y, xy, auto as well as none which allow
detailed control of how panning and zooming operate


R Notebooks (IRkernel) no longer require use of a web service. Simply install Brunel Visualization directly into R and enjoy.

Minor fixes

  • Wrapped text in Firefox browsers has been improved to compensate for the difference in
    how FF calculates text height.

Maps Preview

Published by:

A short update today; we have been working on intelligent mapping for Brunel 1.0 (due in January) and since it’s a subject many people are interested in, we thought we’d put up a “work in progress” video showing how things are progressing. It’s a rough video, so you get to see my inability to type accurately as well as some rough transitions. Showing the video at full resolution is recommended.

Usual disclaimers apply: this is planned for v1.0 in January, we expect it to work as described, but no guarantees — Enjoy!

Brunel 0.8: Enhanced Color mapping

Published by:

The two main new features of Brunel 0.8 are an enhanced UI for building (as described by Dan) and a through re-working of our code for mapping data to color. This post is going to talk about the latter — with a lot of examples!

Twelve Ways to Color Africa

The data set we are using is from We took a subset of the countries and data columns (CSV data)  for this exercise.

These examples are using some prototype code for geographic maps that we are going to introduce into a later version of Brunel (probably v1.0, slated for January), but maps looks so nice, we wanted to use them for this article. Please do not depend on the currently functionality — consider this “advance preview” and highly subject to change.

Because there are a lot of maps, these are not live versions, but static images — click on them to open up a Brunel editor window where you can see it live and make changes.

The Brunel language reference describes the improvements to the color command in detail. Here we just show examples!

Categorical Colors


The above two images are created by the following Brunel:

  • map(‘africa’) x(name) color(language) label(iso) tooltip(#all) style(‘.label{opacity:0.5;text-shadow:none}’)
  • map(‘africa’) x(name) color(language:[white, nominal]) label(iso) tooltip(#all) style(‘.label{opacity:0.5;text-shadow:none}’)

For all our examples, the only changes are the color statement, so from now on we’ll just refer to the color command.

If you use a simple color command, as in the first example, Brunel chooses a suitable palette. In this case “language” is a categorical field, so it chooses a nominal palette. This is a palette of 19 colors chosen to be visually distinct.

The second example specifies which colors we want in the output space. The first category in the “language” field is special, so we ask for a palette consisting of white, then all the usual colors from the nominal palette.

africa4Because we know the data well, we can hand-craft a color mapping here that reflects the language patterns better. I used color(language:[white, red, yellow, green, cyan, green, green, blue, blue, blue, blue, gray, gray, gray, gray, gray])  to use red for lists containing Arabic, green when they contain English, and blue when they contain French. I mixed the colors to show lists where the languages are mixed.

The geographical similarities in languages can be seen pretty easily in the chart, but the colors are a bit bright. Which leads to the following …

For areas and “large” shapes, Brunel automatically creates muted versions of colors, so names like “red” and “green” are less visually dominant and distracting. This can be altered by adding a “=” to the list of colors, which means “leave the colors unmuted”, or a series of asterisks, which means “mute them more”. Here are a couple of examples, using the same basic palette as the previous one


africa7If you have a smaller fixed number of categories in your field, you can use palettes carefully designed to work well for that number. Rather than provide them in Brunel, our suggestion is to go directly to a site that allows you to select them (Cynthia Brewer’s site ColorBrewer is  the standout recommendation) and copy the array of color codes and paste them directly into the Brunel code.

For the example on the right, we did exactly that, using en:[‘#beaed4’, ‘#7fc97f’]) as out colors (the quotes are optional in this list)

Color Ranges

For numeric data, we want to map the data values to a smoothly changing range of values. So, instead of defining individual values, we define values which are intermediate points on a smoothly changing scale of colors. We do this using the same syntax pattern as for categorical data. We are using the latitude of the capital city to color by, rather than a more informative variables, so the color changes can be seen more clearly.


On the left we specified color as color(capital_lat) so we get Brunel’s default blue-red sequential scale. This uses a variety of hues, again taken from ColorBrewer, to provide points along a linear scale of color. On the right we use an explicit color mapping from ColorBrewer, color(capital_lat:[‘#8c510a’, ‘#bf812d’, ‘#dfc27d’, ‘#f6e8c3’, ‘#f5f5f5’, ‘#c7eae5’, ‘#80cdc1’, ‘#35978f’, ‘#01665e’]), where we simply went to the site, found a scale we liked and used the export>Javascript method. Note that Brunel will adapt to to the number of colors in the palette automatically.


The above two charts show the difference between asking for color(capital_lat:reds) and color(capital_lat:red). When a plural is used, it gives a palette that uses multiple hues, with the general tone of the color being requested. With a  singular color request, you only gets shades of that exact hue. Generally we would recommend the former unless you have some specific reason to need the single-hue version.


We can specify multiple colors in the same way as we do for categorical data, using capital_lat:[purpleblues, reds]) on the left and capital_lat:[blue, red]) on the right. When we have exactly two colors defined, we stitch them together, running through a neutral central color, to make a diverging color scale that highlights the low and high values of the field.


Mapping data to color is a tricky business, and in version 0.8 of Brunel our goal is twofold: To ensure that if you only specify a field, a suitable mapping is generated, and second, to allow the output space of colors to be customized for user needs. In future versions of Brunel we will add mapping for the input space, so, for example, we could tie the value mapped to white in the last example to be the equator, not simply midway through the data range. Look for that in a few months!

Villains of Doctor Who

Published by:

I’ve always been a big Doctor Who fan; growing up with the BBC and seeing many incarnations of the Doctor striding across the TV screens, defeating his enemies armed with intelligence, loquaciousness, and a small (admittedly sonic) screwdriver. In particular I recall being terrified of the villains in “The Talons of Weng-Chiang“, which, nowadays, do not seem particularly scary. But the villains of Who have always been magical!

So I was excited to find a data set of Doctor Who villains through 2013 (courtesy of The Guardian) and used it for a short Brunel demo video. I left it as-is for the video, but it was clear the data set needed a bit of cleaning. The column names were more like descriptions than titles, which was annoying, but the biggest issue was the Motivation column, which was more like a description than  categorization. So I edited the data a little — changing the column titles and then providing a manual clustering of motivation into smaller categories, creating three motivation columns: Motivation_Long, the original; and Motivation_Med, Motivation_Short — my groupings of those original categories. With these changes, I saved the resulting CSV file as DoctorWhoVillains.csv. You can check out an overview of the motivation columns in the Brunel Builder.

As usual with data analysis, it took way longer to do the data prep work than to use the results! I quite like this summary visualization, which is simply three shorter ones joined together with Brunel’s ‘|’ operator:

Doctor Who Villains through 2103

Doctor Who Villains through 2103

The bubble chart and word cloud show pretty much the same information — the cloud scales the size by the Log of the number of stories (otherwise the Daleks tend to exterminate any ability to see lesser villains) and is limited to the top 80-ish villains by appearance count. The bottom chart shows when villains first appeared and their motivation. The label in each cell is a representative villain from that cell, so the Sensorites are a representative dominating villain from the 1960-1965 era. The years have been binned into half decades. At a glance, it looks like extermination and domination are common themes early on, whereas self interest is more of a New Who (post-2000) thing. Serving Big Bad is evenly spread out over time.

 The Brunel script for this is quite long, as I wanted to place stuff carefully and add styling:

data('') bubble color(Motivation_Short) size(Episodes) sort(First:ascending) label(Villain) tooltip(Villain, motivation_long, titles) at(0, 0, 60, 60) style('* {font-size: 7pt}') | data('') cloud x(Villain) color(motivation_short) size(LogStories) sort(first:ascending) top(episodes:80) at(40, 0, 100, 55) style(':nth-child(odd) { font-family:Impact;font-style:normal') style(':nth-child(even) { font-family:Times; font-style:italic') style('font-size:100px') | data('') x(motivation_short) y(first) color(episodes:gray) sort(episodes) label(villain) tooltip(titles) bin(first:10) sum(episodes) mode(villain) list(titles) legends(none) at(0, 60, 100, 100) style('label-location:box')

 Without the data and decoration statements, this is what it looks like — three charts concatenated together with the ‘|’ to make an visualization system:

bubble color(Motivation_Short) size(Episodes) sort(First:ascending) label(Villain) tooltip(Villain, motivation_long, titles) 
| cloud x(Villain) color(motivation_short) size(LogStories) sort(first:ascending) top(episodes:80)
| x(motivation_short) y(first) color(episodes:gray) sort(episodes) label(villain) tooltip(titles) bin(first:10) sum(episodes) mode(villain) list(titles) legends(none)

 I was curious about when villains first appeared, so came up with this chart — stacking villains in their year of first appearance (click on it for the live version):

And here are a couple of additional samples I made along the way …

Blogging With Brunel

Published by:


Here’s a short video showing how to create a blog entry using Brunel in a few minutes. The data comes from The Guardian and is completely unmodified, as you can see in the video from the fairly odd column names! I’m making a cleaner version of the data and hope to have some samples of that up in a  few days.

The video is high resolution (1920 x 1080) and about 60M. It’s probably best viewed expanded out to full screen.

Brunel: Open Source Visualization Language

Published by:

BRUNEL is a high-level language that describes visualizations in terms of composable actions. It drives a visualization engine (d3) that performs the actual rendering and interactivity. It provides a language that is as simple as possible to describe a wide variety of potential charts, and to allow them to be used in Java, Javascript, python and R systems that want to deliver web-based interactive visualizations.

At the end of the article are a list of resources, but first, some examples. The dataset I am using for these is a set of data taken from BoardGameGeek which I processed to create a data set describing the top 2000 games listed as of Spring 2015. Each chart below is a fully interactive visualization running in its own frame. I’ve added the brunel description for each chart below each image as a caption, so you can go to the Builder anytime and copy the command into the edit box to try out new things.

data('sample:BGG Top 2000 Games.csv') bubble color(rating) size(voters) sort(rating) label(title) tooltip(title, #all) legends(none) style('* {font-size: 7pt}') top(rating:100)

This shows the top 100 games, with a tooltip view for details on the games. They are packed together in a layout where the location has no strong meaning
— the goal is to show as much data in as small a space as possible!
In the builder, you can change the number in top(rating:100) to show the top 1000, 2000 … or show the bottom 100. You could also add x(numplayers) to divide up the groups by recommended number of players

data('sample:BGG Top 2000 Games.csv') line x(published) y(categories) color(categories) size(voters:200) opacity(#selection) sort(categories) top(published:1900) sum(voters) legends(none) | data('sample:BGG Top 2000 Games.csv') bar y(voters) stack polar color(playerage) label(playerage) sum(voters) legends(none) at(15, 60, 40, 90) interaction(select:mouseover)

This example shows some live interactive features; hover over the pie chart to update the main chart. The main chart shows the number of people voting for games in different categories over time, and the pie chart shows the recommended minimum age to enjoy a game. So when you hover over ‘6’, for example, you can see that there have been no good sci-fi games for younger players in the last 10 years. Use the mouse to pan and zoom the chart (drag to pan, double-click to zoom).

data('sample:BGG Top 2000 Games.csv') treemap x(designer, mechanics) color(rating) size(#count) label(published) tooltip(#all, title) mean(rating) min(published) list(title:50) legends(none)

Head to the Builder Site to modify this. You could try:

  • change the list of fields in x(…) — reorder then or use fields like ‘numplayers’, ‘language’
  • remove the ‘legends(none)’ command to show a legend
  • change size to ‘voters’ — and add a ‘sum(voters)’ command to show the total number of voters rather than just counts for each treemap tile

Do you want to know more?

Follow links below; gallery and cookbook examples will take you to the Brunel Builder Site where you can create your own visualizations and grab some Javascript code to embed them in your web pages … which is exactly how I built the above examples!

A Quick Look at Lots of Songs …

Published by:

Songs by year, rating and genre

A Quick Look at Lots of Songs …

Songs by year, rating and genre

iTunes information about my songs, showing year, genre and my ratings

A quick visualization of the songs in my iTunes database. I was curious to see if there were any sweet spots in my listening history. As always, showing correlation between three different variables is hard, and here I wanted one dot per song, so the density is quite high (clicking on the image to show it full size is recommended).

Perhaps the most interesting thing for me personally was that I though i liked Alternative music more than I actually appear to. I notice especially that the 2010-2015 bin for mid-value rating is dominated by Alternative!

Appropriate Mappings

Published by:


Vox Article on viral memes and charitable giving

First, a disclaimer. This is not a post about the actual issues this article raises; just about the presentation of those claims. The image from the article has appeared in numerous places and been referenced by a number of news sources, as well as appearing in my Facebook and twitter feeds.

And it’s a bad image.

One minor issue is that it is hard to work out which circle relates to which disease, as the name of the disease only appears on the legend, so you are constantly moving your eyes from grey dot on left to the legend, to the grey dot on the right. Hard to make much sense. The fact that the legend doesn’t seem to have any order to it doesn’t help either. If this were 20 diseases instead of eight, the chart would be doomed!

Kudos for picking appropriate colors though. It helps that they used a natural mapping (pink <–> breast cancer; red <–> AIDS) that might help a bit.

The more worrying issue is that it makes a classic distortion mistake; look at the right side and rapidly answer the question, using just the images, not the text: “How many more deaths are there due to the purple disease than the blue disease?” 

Using the image as a guide, your answer is likely to be in the range 10 to 20 times as man, because the ratio of the areas is about that amount. When you look at the text, though, it’s actually only about four times. The numbers are not encoding the area, which is what we see, but they are encoding the radius (or diameter) which we do not immediately perceive.

The result is a sensationalist chart. It takes a real difference, but sensationalizes it by exaggerating the difference dramatically. If you want to use circles, map the variable of interest to AREA, not RADIUS. It fits our perceptions much more truthfully. It’s not actually perfect; we tend to see small circles as larger than they really are; but it’s much, much better).

So, here’s a reworking:

WhereWeDonate Vs. Diseases That Kill

I tried to keep close to the original color mappings, as they are pretty good, but have used width to encode the variable of interest, keeping the height of the rectangle fixed. I also labeled the items on both sides so we can see much more easily that heart disease kills about 4x as many people as Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease. 

I also added some links between the two disease rankings to help visually link the two and aid navigation. The result is, I believe, not only more truthful, but easier to use. In short, it works.

Comics and Visualization

Published by:

Understanding Comics book cover; Scott McCloudComics and Visualization

Although this book is over a decade old now (and Scott has a number of later books that follow on from this one), this is still a highly valuable book to read, getting great review from famous artists as a fundamental resource for comic book writers. I read this from the perspective of a visualization expert, and found a number of interesting points in the book, especially the earlier sections. He defines comics as “juxtaposed pictorial and other images in deliberate sequence, intended to covey information and/or to produce an aesthetic response in the viewer (p.9)”, which, to my mind, allows many visualizations to fits his definition! The concept of small multiples, when presented in a “deliberate order” such as via a trellis display, fits particularly well into this definition, so I was encouraged to read on. Some highlights of the book, from my point of view:

  • The use of simpler icons / symbols to make depictions of reality more universal; that argument resonates more strongly with me than Tukey’s data-ink concept. I feel more convinced by the argument that additional detail is bad when it makes it harder for us to understand the high-level picture because it draws us too much into the physicality of the shapes being used.
  • McCloud presents a triangular space, the vertices of which are “reality”, “language” and “the picture plane” into which comic styles can be placed. I think there is also value in looking at various styles of visualization and seeing where they fit in. Treemaps, for example, have more “realistic” versions using cushions, while keeping the same structure. Scientific, geographic or fluid display visualizations are more realistic than, say, statistical graphics.
  • Less is More” applied to the number of intermediate representations used — this argues that for visualizations of, say, a process evolving over time, we should not simply slice at even times, but instead look for important features we want to show, and show fewer frames.
  • Lots of good stuff on how time is perceived when displayed at a sequence.
  • Can Emotions be Visible?” is the motivating question for chapter five — I would be very curious to see if we could apply his ideas to visualizations — maybe people like pie charts because they seem warm, serene and quiet, whereas a line chart with gridlines is rational, conservative and dynamic?

As an aside, I included a comic in my book on Visualizing Time, more as a whimsy than anything else, but I’m glad that I have at least a tenuous link with Scott McClouds’s highly recommended book! comics

Visualizing Tennis

Published by:

I’m a member of the American Statistical Association’s “Statistics in Sport” section ( and I’m also British by birth, so Andy Murray’s success at Wimbledon this year was interesting to me for two reasons. I took a look at some of the data on Murray (collected by IBM’s SlamTracker initiative — ) with a view to doing a little visual analysis, so now I have another reason to be interested …

I found some data on his performance over a few years leading up to Wimbledon 2013 and wanted to look at trends. Now usually I prefer to create several linked visualizations and look at them together, but for this data I found that several of the stats I was interested in worked nicely when plotted in the same system. Here’s what I came up with:


Continue reading